1
Apocalypse World / Re: 2nd Edition and Seize by Force (and similar moves)
« on: January 25, 2017, 05:07:00 AM »
Munin, I will be doing things pretty much as you have laid out. I 'd rather the spiffy new 2nd edition had clearly said that SBF 6- could still include a hard move. Other moves do express that a hard move should be expected on a 6-, so ambiguity or purposely missing text opens the door for disagreement on how SBF is meant to work. Probably not a big problem, but you never know how people will react when things happen to their character and they think the rules say otherwise.
On an unrelated note, I wish the playbooks contained a line in the box for the advanced moves saying when they become available. New players always try to select one of the advanced moves, because there's nothing saying otherwise, and it seems like such an easy problem to prevent.
DeadmanwalkingXI, I apologize if I came across poorly. I agree with your point about players being able to reduce the odds even further of getting a 6-. In my mind, this only emphasizes the idea that a 6- should remain a potentially bad thing. Not always bad. Not a way to punish the character or player. But, when it happens, it's my chance to figure out a way to make the character's life interesting. I guess we'll all have a better idea as we get a chance to see the moves in action.
On an unrelated note, I wish the playbooks contained a line in the box for the advanced moves saying when they become available. New players always try to select one of the advanced moves, because there's nothing saying otherwise, and it seems like such an easy problem to prevent.
DeadmanwalkingXI, I apologize if I came across poorly. I agree with your point about players being able to reduce the odds even further of getting a 6-. In my mind, this only emphasizes the idea that a 6- should remain a potentially bad thing. Not always bad. Not a way to punish the character or player. But, when it happens, it's my chance to figure out a way to make the character's life interesting. I guess we'll all have a better idea as we get a chance to see the moves in action.