I'm thinking about starting a hack set immediately after an apocalyptic event (probably keeping cause vague/fluid), like in the first weeks and months. I thought of this after noticing a distinct lack of early-apocalypse RPGs (at least in the non-zombie context). Think Day of the Triffids, The Stand, etc. I feel like this setting, with its focus on ordinary people adapting to a new reality (contrast deep apoc, where everyone has either survived this long or was born into wasteland life and so is definitionally likely to be at least somewhat a badass), and on conflict between survival at all costs and holding on to/rebuilding civilization is good fodder for storytelling/character-driven roleplaying.
Some ideas I'm tossing about:
-Stats focused on character/personality play a central role
--Opposed stat pairs, still working on mechanics (see other post)
---Opposition will both impact character development and drive character interaction/conflict
--GUTsiness: Acting under fire (similar to cool), getting the drop; opposes CAU
--CAUtion: Checking for danger, searching for supplies; opposes GUT
--HARdness: Hesitation check when making first attack against non-openly-hostile human or docile animal; opposes COM
--COMpassion: Relieving trauma, reading people; opposes HAR
--Two simple aptitude/ability based stats, FITness and WITs, play a mostly secondary role and naturally converge regardless on starting point (the longer you survive, the more get into shape and learn the ins and outs of survival)
-Four-stat persuasion mechanic: Dealing with other survivors always carries the risk of violence, but any survivor who turns to it as a first resort will not be a survivor long. To this end, each personality trait has a persuasion method associated with it, with likelihood of success of each varying by circumstances.
--GUT: Appeal to expediency
--CAU: Appeal to reason
--HAR: Threat of force/intimidation
--COM: Appeal to emotion/humanity
-Story-based advancement: When choosing advancement options, a player must justify that choice by reference to story events--for example, to take a plus to a personality trait, player must reference an event that had a galvanizing effect and describe why it had that result. E.g., "When we shot those looters, and I saw that kid lying dead on the ground—he couldn't have been more than 14—I realized how important it is that we hold on to our humanity; if we lose that why even survive?" (+1 COM), alternately, "When we had to take down those looters, I realized it's them and us in this wasteland—and damned if I'm going to let it be us." (+1 HAR).
-Starting character archetypes ("classes") based on pre-collapse life (some ideas: law enforcement, medical professional, counselor, office worker, construction worker, farmer, doomsday-prepper, criminal), with advancement initially tied to background but eventually gaining access to broader category of increases
-Physical and mental health—in addition to tracking wounds, characters rack up trauma for experiencing the horrors of survival, sources of trauma may vary based on stat values or background. Higher trauma levels have escalating effects, eventually up to and including total breakdown/permanent personality changes.
-(aspirational) Scalability from wandering band of survivors through crude strongholds through building new society from the ruins
Welcome thoughts and suggestions!