As the cleric player, I thought it was awesome and I had no idea you didn't prep much. I figured we were just resolving a front we'd left hanging. I've been a DM for 20 years and didn't notice. It was seamless.
Everything that was established and developed about Bendito from the get-go led up to that point, at least that's the feeling I got when I was immersed in my character at that moment. And I wasn't even that drunk when I made the decision to stay. I figure it's a good NPC for you to use later or maybe I can pick him back up as a PC if the story goes in that direction down the road. (Level differences seem to not matter much and I don't care about that stuff anyway.) I also felt that the party has started to depart from Brother Bendito's core values, though I think the cleric made his impact on them. And relinquishing my character in a satisfying way was so much better than getting buckwheated in a spiked pit trap. (Well, depends on the pit trap, I guess, but you get the idea.) I was even able to resolve a bond that hopefully brought the remaining characters closer together before retiring.
I know the thief player personally and any objection he had was to the pace and/or delivery. He's used to a more DM-focused game and this threw him a bit. I don't think he was prepared for exactly how much freedom and control players are given. He understands the possibilities now and can come at it fresh next time with better perspective. Possibly the online format was a problem as well as this was his first foray into an online game. If you're not used to it, a 5-second pause can seem like an eternity even though more gets done in an online game than an in-person one as there are fewer distractions. Plus you don't have to smell other people's farts. It's like one of those jokes on Family Guy that runs about 5 - 10 seconds longer than they need to. You really notice that in the silence of one's lonely basement. It's just a perception thing that you overcome with further online games.
Big thumbs up from everyone I talked to. The thief player just needs a new character I think. He was set on cleric until he realized there couldn't be more than one represented in the party. I told him not to dream about anything before he sat down. Neverthless, with Brother Bendito out of the way, here's his chance...