My first session is this Wednesday. And I've not GM'd for over two years (and as I'm the only of my friends that suggests RPGs, not RP'd).
Having scoured the boards, I'm going to make up +1 -1 and so on tokens for people who take them forward, probably Hold tokens too to stop people forgetting they've got Hold (which I can see them doing if it's only noted on the sheets).
In terms of looks, I've also found my oldest most-missmatched d6s. (c: I may also see if I can find some stubby well worn pencils.
My usual "new game" routine is to buy fresh stationery, and amusingly it's fun to do it this way too...