16
Apocalypse World / Re: Playbook expansion: The Shark
« on: August 18, 2013, 07:05:10 AM »
No recursion!
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
It would be interesting to have something that dealt with parenthood stuff. How a vat born's relationship with the vatlord turns out. Mother figure, separation anxiety, Oedipus complex, incestuous desires and so on.
Sort of how screwed up the vat born became by not having been born by actual human parents and how it project that on to the vatlord.
I think this is going to very challenging to convey using only the tools of the written moves. Just for example, having the Vatlord or MC choose a trait makes it seem like that trait should be the defining trait of the NPC in question, when in fact it would merely be one trait among many in a regularly-generated human being. The trait-choice feels more like a dramatic, player-level choice than an in-fiction choice. I mean it is obvious that if a person is smart, they might also be athletic or beautiful or hungry or whatever, and that any of these traits may be more or less definining to them.
Similarly, it seems pointless to try and make an exhaustive trait list; I would far rather see a much shorter list that has obvious gaps in it, so as to make it clear that these choices are not exhaustively determining the total composition of the person.
I think it is also strange to have players interacting directly with threat types, which are generally MC-side tools. Again it feels weirdly deterministic, to know a threat-type in advance of seeing the NPC interact with the world. Maybe that is the weirdness you are going for, though.