With 1st edition history, the owner of the playbook told one player how their Hx would work. Now the question is posed to the group, and one person answers. What happens if more than one person thinks that designation applies to them? That is to say, who gets the final call on Hx? The MC, the owner, or the group?

Play by post. Considering you are planning on filming it, I guess not.

I just saw the new Suicide Squad trailer, and then I found this. Must be fate.

When you say super-powered, does that mean each character is predominately based around being a hero, and are they simply given these powers to do with as they will? I remember a PBTA hack recently were the moves, agenda and palybooks themselves were all geared entirely towards saving people, knocking out rather than killing villians, and generally being a traditional superhero. Is that going to be the case here?

Where as the Harbinger is kind of a give and take between the Master and the Servant, the Crusader is a devoted worshipper of their master, and whenever... wait, whats that? HERESY!? SMITED!

^ is what happens a lot. Going for the Mad Paladin approach.

Double post because OMG THOSE SIGNATURE MOVES.

I have no idea whether to play it straight, make everything a hilarious exaggeration or JUST MURDER EVERYTHING.

BLOOD FOR THE BLOOD GOD, SKULLS FOR THE SKULL GOD, MILK FOR THE KHORNE FLAKES!

I love it.

Looks much better. I love the implied 'but if you don't choose this option, then... good luck!' The 'act vaguely upon instinct' is still in there somewhere, right? Part of the creation process. It needs that.

I'll cut you a deal, you can mess around with Swarm however you like, if you'll proofread this move for the Skinjacker:

When you come into direct skin contact with a viable host, even for an instant, you can switch bodies. Roll+sly. On a 10+, choose 1, on a 7-9, choose 2. On a miss, you can still switch if you want. If you are really, really sure.
- Spend 1 Creep
- Your new body is stunned for a moment
- Your old host isn't stunned for a moment, and realises they've been 'jacked
- Anyone paying close attention notices the switch

Not sure if this would be a normal move, or a signature. I just feel it needs it.

Regarding the social vs. aggro, perhaps encouraging RP etc. while in the Afterlife would be more in line through mechanics would be appropriate, because every single one of these playbooks is either a killing machine, or has a significant mind control/influence shtick.

I am perfectly fine with this.

You said it yourself: B-movie horror flick. Keep repeating that to yourself, and you'll see that everything is fine. The Afterlife is backstage. While in the mortal realm, things die. Things die hard, and messy, and in various hilarious and creepily creative ways.

This is a good thing.

Addendum: Have you asked any of your players how they felt it went? Confide in them that everything went off the rails (for you at least), and perhaps whether what they did resulted in that. See what responses you get. I'd certainly be interested.