1
Apocalypse World / Re: A question of scale
« on: January 10, 2011, 02:53:18 PM »
I tinkered more with gang sizes in last nights session, and it didn't really work. Doesn't do social or read-the-sitch stuff at all. Fine for combat (more fine grained than whole tiers) though. How to manipulate a group of people was a problem I had and couldn't resolve well.
I really like the tiering idea - I'd come to similar numbers while contemplating it. The 3 jump from +4 to +1 nicely matches the 3 width of a partial success. Though I would be tempted to move the exceptional success to 13+ to avoid some odd probability steps.
The +/-1 seems a bit small scale, prone to very arbitrary judgements. Big scale steps are usually more clear from the fiction.
I like the custom strategic moves, but I fear having to produce them for every threat, and keeping them consistent across threats.
I'm in the process of prepping a hack for a fantasy/clock punk version of 18th century Edinburgh (Scotland) to convert a current campaign that is completely unsuited to it's current system.
Given it has everything from normal people to highlander style immortals and faerie kings it needs bit of scale...
I hadn't spotted all those different approaches,
many thanks for highlighting them.
Alan.
I really like the tiering idea - I'd come to similar numbers while contemplating it. The 3 jump from +4 to +1 nicely matches the 3 width of a partial success. Though I would be tempted to move the exceptional success to 13+ to avoid some odd probability steps.
The +/-1 seems a bit small scale, prone to very arbitrary judgements. Big scale steps are usually more clear from the fiction.
I like the custom strategic moves, but I fear having to produce them for every threat, and keeping them consistent across threats.
I'm in the process of prepping a hack for a fantasy/clock punk version of 18th century Edinburgh (Scotland) to convert a current campaign that is completely unsuited to it's current system.
Given it has everything from normal people to highlander style immortals and faerie kings it needs bit of scale...
I hadn't spotted all those different approaches,
many thanks for highlighting them.
Alan.